Reminder #2: See below. I also attached a copy of the specification for your consideration.

Thanks,

- Mark

The final release candidate for the first version of the OpenChain specification is available for public comments on the OpenChain wiki at:

      https://wiki.linuxfoundation.org/_media/openchain/openchainspec-2016-05-16-1.pdf

The public comments phase, which represents the last step in the release process, began last week and will remain open for 30 days closing on June 17^th.  

Please feel free to post comments about this current version by using one of the following methods:

·        to this mailing list;

·        at the next upcoming OpenChain Specification meeting on June 6^th at 9am PST; or

·        to me at mark.gisi@... if you prefer to remain anonymous.

Thanks,

- Mark

Hi Mark,

Great document, a few minor comments…

Introduction: Interesting though it is, I don’t think I’d include all the historical view if it isn’t particularly relevant…especially where it may be upsetting for people to know that they weren’t being trusted by their customers. ;)

1.2 1.2.3: A goal of >85% is a great target, but I wonder if it’s realistic, particularly for any (large) organisation. It may also be helpful to have a ramp-up. E.g. at least 60% in yr1, etc.

G3, 3.2: Suggest to change “FOSS program” to “FOSS management program” as it is called in G6.

G4, 4.1: I’d add something about including “build instructions”, as potentially unbuildable or only buildable using proprietary toolchain source isn’t appreciated.   

Hope that helps,

Martin.

Reminder #2: See below. I also attached a copy of the specification for your consideration.

Thanks,

- Mark

The final release candidate for the first version of the OpenChain specification is available for public comments on the OpenChain wiki at:

      https://wiki.linuxfoundation.org/_media/openchain/openchainspec-2016-05-16-1.pdf

The public comments phase, which represents the last step in the release process, began last week and will remain open for 30 days closing on June 17^th.  

Please feel free to post comments about this current version by using one of the following methods:

·         to this mailing list;

·         at the next upcoming OpenChain Specification meeting on June 6^th at 9am PST; or

·         to me at mark.gisi@... if you prefer to remain anonymous.

Thanks,

- Mark

Hi Martin,

Thank you for the helpful comments. We will give it consideration at the next Specification meeting.

best,

Mark

Hi Mark,

Great document, a few minor comments…

Introduction: Interesting though it is, I don’t think I’d include all the historical view if it isn’t particularly relevant…especially where it may be upsetting for people to know that they weren’t being trusted by their customers. ;)

1.2 1.2.3: A goal of >85% is a great target, but I wonder if it’s realistic, particularly for any (large) organisation. It may also be helpful to have a ramp-up. E.g. at least 60% in yr1, etc.

G3, 3.2: Suggest to change “FOSS program” to “FOSS management program” as it is called in G6.

G4, 4.1: I’d add something about including “build instructions”, as potentially unbuildable or only buildable using proprietary toolchain source isn’t appreciated.   

Hope that helps,

Martin.

Reminder #2: See below. I also attached a copy of the specification for your consideration.

Thanks,

- Mark

The final release candidate for the first version of the OpenChain specification is available for public comments on the OpenChain wiki at:

      https://wiki.linuxfoundation.org/_media/openchain/openchainspec-2016-05-16-1.pdf

The public comments phase, which represents the last step in the release process, began last week and will remain open for 30 days closing on June 17^th.  

Please feel free to post comments about this current version by using one of the following methods:

·        to this mailing list;

·        at the next upcoming OpenChain Specification meeting on June 6^th at 9am PST; or

·        to me at mark.gisi@... if you prefer to remain anonymous.

Thanks,

- Mark